Pr. Alan DERSHOWITZ: 'The Intifada was globalized in Amsterdam'

0
4K

On university campuses throughout the world, there have been chants demanding that the violent intifada – which killed thousands of Israeli children, women and other civilians – be "globalized." 

 

Last week, we witnessed the first significant manifestation of that demand in Amsterdam, where large groups of predominantly Arab and Muslim rioters physically attacked Israelis and Jews who had been cheering for an Israeli soccer team.

Although some of the media tried to blame the attacks on Israelis, the evidence strongly suggests that this pogrom was planned well in advance and would have taken place even if there had been no provocation by Israeli fans.

What some Israeli fans are accused of doing is all too typical of European soccer "hooligans": tearing down the opposing team's flags – in this instance Palestinian flags – and shouting racist epithets, but there is no evidence of any violence directed against pro-Palestinian individuals by Israelis or Jews. The violence was ALL perpetrated by anti-Israel and anti-Jewish rioters against Israeli and Jewish victims.

There is no moral or legal equivalence between non-violent mischief — such as tearing down flags and shouting racial insults — and committing life-threatening assaults upon people based on their religion and ethnicity. The anti-Israel rioters were hunting down Jews, compelling victims to beg for their lives by denying they were Jewish.

Without justifying the shouting of racial slurs by some Israelis, it is important to remember Sigmund Freud's brilliant insight that "civilization began on the day the first human hurled an insult rather than a spear at his opponent."

Muslim extremists have a long history of hurling spears in response to non-violent insults. Recall the numerous deadly attacks — shootings, stabbings, bombings and lethal fatwas—against those who allegedly insulted the prophet by picturing him or authoring books about him. There was also violence against those who burned Korans or otherwise demeaned Islam. Even cartoons provoked deadly responses.

The law in no Western nation grants the victims of non-violent insults the right to respond by violence. If a Jew were to physically assault the many Muslims who have repeatedly demeaned Judaism or its nation-state during recent protests, they would be appropriately punished, as some have been.

This attempt to justify the violence committed is yet another manifestation of the rancid double standard imposed by the media and others against all things Jewish. It also reflects widespread acceptance of the racist excuse that "Muslims will be Muslims" when it comes to violently responding to insults.

Evidence strongly suggests that the violence in Amsterdam was planned and coordinated well in advance of any non-violent provocations, and would have occurred even if no flags had been taken down and no insults shouted. Also, many non-Arab and non-Muslim Dutch antisemites cheered on the attackers, reflecting the long-standing and deep Jew-hatred that has been part of Dutch culture since before the Holocaust. The Netherlands was among the most pro-Nazi nations in Europe during World War II, and after the war took little action against Dutch people who collaborated with the German occupiers.

Not surprisingly, the Amsterdam police did not do enough to stem last week's violence, and law enforcement authorities quickly freed most of the rioters, including those who committed assaults.

Leaders of the Dutch government eventually apologized and took measures to prevent recurrences. But we are likely to see more anti-Israeli and anti-Jewish pogroms in other parts of the world as antisemitism moves from the fringes to the mainstream. Unless something proactive is done, it's coming to a theater – or stadium – near you.

Protestors – both pro- and anti-Israel – have the right to express their views verbally and even symbolically, but they have no right to attack individuals or groups based on religion, ethnicity or national origin. Those who engaged in physical assaults – and many were caught on video – must be prosecuted and, if convicted, imprisoned or deported. A clear line must be drawn between lawful, even if immoral, protests, and criminal violence. There is no continuum. It is a bright-line distinction that many in the media are deliberately trying to blur.

The U.S. has a stake in stopping this violence: the call to "globalize the intifada" is not limited to Europe. Those who advocate globalization are inciting violence against Americans of Jewish heritage. The incitement may be too general to be denied First Amendment protection against criminal punishment, but the single standard demands that universities apply the same standard to calls for intifada than they would to calls for lynching of blacks or assaulting of gays.

The real difference is that no university student or faculty member would ever call for the latter, and if they did, they would be disciplined or expelled. Yet today it is entirely acceptable, indeed expected, that radical students will call for the lynching and assaulting of Jews and Israelis. That, after all, is what an intifada entails.

Some may argue that the literal meaning of intifada includes non-violent actions, but many of those who hear the call to globalize the intifada understand it to justify violence of the type seen in Amsterdam – and worse.

 

***

 

 

Like
1
Site içinde arama yapın
CryptoCurrency Rates
Kategoriler
Read More
Analysis
New tech plays role in Gaza war, but not to level Israel once envisioned
"When technology replaces humans, it comes at the cost of dulling human intuition and research...
By Israel Swords of Iron Ops 2023-11-14 12:23:06 0 10K
Cloak & Dagger
[PART #2 - Unit 504] The IDF shadow on the battle field
Unit 504 is one of the most secret units that deal with intel inside the Arab population,...
By NavyVetUnited 2024-12-15 09:02:17 0 3K
News & Politics
Ukraine, Middle East, new world order: main points from Putin's keynote address at SPIEF 25
Russia views all of Ukraine as its own, but does not deny the country’s right to...
By NavyVetUnited 2025-06-21 06:47:44 0 2K
News & Politics
Testimony after testimony, the horrifying scope of the rapes on Oct. 7th becomes clear
Dr. Kochav Elkayam-Levi directs the world's gaze to one of the nightmarish episodes in the events...
By Israel Swords of Iron Ops 2023-12-03 09:57:27 0 10K
Real Time Facts
Sydney Jews Fear for Their Safety After Large-Scale Antisemitic Vandalism
Buildings and cars were spray painted and some were torched causing $100,000 of damage  ...
By Israel Swords of Iron Ops 2024-11-24 12:56:58 0 4K
X-Pulse, the HO1 Think Tank https://thinktank.x-pulse.org/